When a man loves a woman-joshua5.pianoman- colton/we’ve got tonight-phillip4.whole lotta love- elise3.and i am telling you- jessica2.I will always love you- Jessica1.Man’s Man’s world-joshua. Maybe then I can understand his following. Lets also count Jennifer Hudson who didnt even make it to the finals yet she is successful. Heejun – (C-) I feel very bad for the winner because they will become a slave to a coulture that will stab them in the heart as soon as they stop being “COOL”. hey mary…you should retire on watching AI…your ears are already malfunctioning…don’t give any bias comment…. My vote for that honer would go to either Jessica’s “I will always love you” or Joshua’s “It’s a man’s world. ” kidding…love to all the American Idol family. It was not hollie’s best, but I still enjoy her more. There’s a thin line between liking the person and liking the performer. Best of the night – Jessica, Phillip (though I was not so much into the variation arrangement of “Movin Out” and …definitely, definitely it was Colton’s moment to shine as a young “Piano Man”… as to the rest… huhummm they all seem to fade into the background after a laugh or two from Heejun.. Jessica sang the song perfertly, the rest were doing karoeke. Thanks so much for pointing out the totally unnecessary Tommy segment. Her version of “Shameless” which is one of the all time great country songs, sung by Garth Brooks did nothing for me. He also actually sang a Billy Joel song like its supposed to be sung! I wish AI would get a little more modern with their song themes. People who dont like jessica are the very people who never liked her in the first place! AND why did you delete my first comment? I do not remember it being any where near this bad last year. Brilliant! 6. Please keep in mind that these predictions are based only on how I think America’s votes might play out. I read her bio, she did not start singing until she was 15, that young lady has come a long way in 3 years. But if u dont the like the artist perse, everything about her/him wouldnt be okay! Hollie needs some voice lesson. Braden and Matthew should have blocked these fanatic Pinoys from taking over the site, it ruined it for normal people. Dafuq. And they have given people a bad attitude toward Pinoys in general. Aside from that… I agree with everything! perfect choice for #1 —. She’s not overrated. Philip – (A) I hope you will be safe next week. The show aired on Wednesdays and Thursdays at 8/7c. Deandre doesn’t even deserve to be in this competition anymore hes a snoozefest the only decent performance was when he sang to get in the top 13 n that wasn’t even that great. JMHO…..I’m not the biggest supporter of Jessica but her “I Will Always Love You” was THE closest rendition to Whitney Houston I’ve ever heard. Beat that! I am starting to like the Voice better because of the judges. Enough with the tasteless vocal gymnastics already. Thought she was great tonight. 5. have preferred Elise singing this, but I’ll take Erika. he has his own opinion, respect it…but still a very lame & not credible opinion…jessica rocks!!!! "American Idol" - Top Ten Results - March 31, 2010 Performance: Ruben Studdard singing "Don't Make 'Em Like You No More" Looks like the "Velvet Teddy Bear" has lost a bit of his fur, slimming down quite a bit. Let’s wish the last two standing the best for tonight’s performance! Is 16 your age? But because it’s your own, and nobody else’s but your opinion I personally do not care. I think he was praised a little too much. I Surrender- kelly clarkson I also do not agree that Joshua’s performance last week was the best ever on Idol. not true… Jessica was amazing! People who don’t connect w/ Jessica maybe because in her first 2 pre-ambles she had the ready made excuse (her voice problems) & then the “I’m taking a risk” comment before her next one. Just Wondering but I will respect your opinion. Elise – kinda safe within the this week but let’s see coz her last two performance never had a MARK!my 2 cents. Please get rid of Tommy F’ing Hillfinger. If she wins, I think its time for AI to hang up it’s hat and let the more interesting singing competition shows have episodes more than once a week…. Elise was really safe because of the judges over-pimping her.I don’t really know why you came up with a B+ performance from Erika. I am going to simply list ten performances that stand out in my head as memorable. Heejun’s jokes are too annoying already. xxxooo *would someone teach Randy to say more than Yo and Dog?”…hopefully Idol will spring for a tutor for him this year. 5/3/2020, American Idol 2012: Top 10 Results Show Tonight | American Idol 2012, American Idol 2012 Top 10 Week Ratings Dip | American Idol 2012. Stuttering – Jessica Sanchez It’s all a mystery to me. And even though he was going for laughs with his performance, I thought the Hilfiger bit was funnier. All HEEJUN performances..(hahah,, sorry HEEJUN fans), Why is masterblaster in your list? Some artist are like that. I did not think I liked Skyler at all until she hit the top 13. Amen. 13 – Hollie Cavanagh “The Climb” I think that her singing a song about New York if she’s a Red Sox fan was a good idea, but she probably liked it. You are so beautiful- jessica sanchez It’s personal preference. What? heejun, as i said before, is this season’s sanjaya. !!!! Let Jessica be herself..no experience like yours.! Well, when the next line is Go Team Jessica or Jessica Rocks, I have a pretty good idea…, all of her fans or some of her fans ???? My favorite is Josh, but I’m not gonna act like he deserves the highest rating every single week. ), Joshua(He needs to stop screaming all the way through his songs or it’s going to get old fast. Ultimately, I think Deandre should go home. This time another criticism is that she doesn’t connect to the audience, the mentors and the song. Aside from the bad advice from Diddy and Tommy Hilfiger, that is. She was way better than everybody, and then you give Heejun an F for actually singing Billy Joel, him and Jessica were the only preformances I enjoyed watching, maybe because I was asleep until Heejun sang and luckily it was close enough to the end for me to see Jessica and Colton (who put me to sleep with his cover of Piano Man that made me cringe). A song I wasn’t familiar HeeJun, please do everyone a favor and volunteer to go home! 3. she will move on after Idol. Phillips – U Got It Bad She should definetly not be in the bottom 3 with that performance. I could quibble about some of these but not your first choice…Elise was amazing. When you have a power like that, maybe you should just be fair to your judging, stating the obvious and refraining from using this as a way of your personal agenda. Do we have the same list?? btw. The Billy Joel of late 70’s and early 80’s was in the summer of his life and hot on the charts; he was not always the more serious singer of his autumn years. Bottom … I thought it was good … but not as good as the best of the night … B, I forgot to add Skylar into the mix. I don’t want to make an argument which one of Jessica/Elise/Hollie/Erika has the best recording voice. Jessica Sanchez I like that post. 4- Jessica Sanchez- She is really good but , but on tonights preformance it wasn’t that good and she sang one of his least known songs he had. 3. I understand her technical abilities, but her performances to me are starting to feel, I don’t know – maybe all vocal trick, no heart, maybe? Like really? … B, 4- Elise- I love a girl with a blusy voice and Elise did this song well. What the hell is your gay issue? Yes he should. To love somebody – Joshua Ledet i don’t think she deserved A+ this week cause it wasn’t her best, she could do way better. They are way better at critiquing and I like them a lot more. Is gibberish your second language? That is crystal clear. I just hope if she does end up having the least votes, that the judges won’t save her… If they do.. they’ll waste the save because Elise cannot win this season. poor in the first half of the song, but by the end he was honestly hitting some And maybe, just maybe that she wanted to be judged based on her singing abilities. There is something about Joshua that puts me off. Colton (A+) The tenth season of American Idol premiered on January 19, 2011, and concluded on May 25, 2011, on the Fox television network. She is still young just like Jessica ?? Alright, now for everyone to disagree with me even more. ‘American Idol’ 2012: Top 10 perform Billy Joel songs. Her voice is sick! How do u connect with Hollie ?? Then, they go and put others down any time they say anything less than praise for her. Nixauc, stop. Worst: DeAndre and Heejun, Deandre – Only The Good Die Young – It was the wrong song American Idol 2012 Finale: Top 2 Performs Tonight, American Idol 2012: Randy Jackson Talks What It Takes To Win, I totally disagre with your list. (C -), Erika – New York State Of Mind – A good song choice. Oh! Colton = [A+]. A+, Elise – purely talent. We both know how blogs work and I do think that you are influencial. Post idol, whether she wins or not, she will be following either the footsteps of JHud or Fantasia Barrino. I’m just surprised that no one said anything about that. What experience?like your experience? Leave this song alone, when I just heard he was singing the song I cringed, when I heard him sing it with his punk rockish tone I cringed even more. if you dont like reggae so be it but that doesn’t mean it was on of the worst performances. Erika(The hair saved her because it gave her a unique look and finally separated her from the rest of the group. I would go as far as saying Hollie should replace her in the “bottom performers” because she sang out of tune. I think she was the best tonight. That’s coming from a rock icon! Can you even imagine how will it sound? If so, the ranking figures. Lighten up. Heejun has had the worst performance two weeks in a row now; he needs to go. That was FLAWLESS. We saw last week, she isn’t very good at upbeat. Your list should be based on reader’s votes.. Smh, 10. I never had an opinion about them before, but now I see them as rude, pushy, aggressive people and will avoid them if possible. Yeah that’s right. Clap Clap Clap. 3. ITS TIME FOR A CHANGE. 9. (B+), Skylar Laine, “Shameless.” I never realized this song was the same song that Garth Brooks had done until she started singing. 16 – Skylar Laine “The Show Must Go On” Steady in her top spot is Jessica Sanchez who has yet to be beat in our weekly polls. Deandre, however, probably doesn’t stand a chance to get the judges’ save. 9.Sometimes I cry- deandre Uh..she wasn’t the frontliner last night. It’s as if she’s connected to everyone in there. 6) Jessica – And I’m Telling You Ford Commercial:"You Found Me." Jessica Sanchez(She is still on top and may have even gotten another boost tonight as I thought even with her low notes she sounded amazing. tried watching The Voice twice but it was totally boring and their battle round is a setup.. a little predictable.. but the best idols, phillip and colton. I love Elise’s rendition of that Led Zep song over among Idol rock performers. Joshua – If You Don’t Know Me By Now America will tire of his antics eventually. If anything, I’d think she could earn a few more from it. He seems incapable of taking this opportunity seriously and his vocal skills are not good enough to be dissing the mentors and the judges. She hit “It was perfect.” ….and I agree and Jessica deserves A+++, sorry I dont agree with your ratings with Jessica dear writer, You are so biased. They’re not even UGLY to start with! Joshua = [B] 5/10/2020, American Idol 2020 Top 7 Performances Recap: A Salute To Moms, American Idol Results: Who Went Home Last Night On American Idol? I love Hollie. I think your biases are starting to color your judgment. In order to make this list I had to be able to envision the person on stage in the actual original performance, the song title and the performer’s name. Sucks! This way, they would be able to have a chance to make up for it. BTW..she’s not ugly. I don’t get it, the poll ask who was the best. To me, she is a good mix between Lauren and dare I say Haley from last year. I’m beginning to smell a little Hollie-favoritism with this author. There are other great performances. She is a total performer! Sweet dreams- jessica sanchez I can clearly see that you love PP, Hollie and Colton. God bless the child- jacob lusk (not on love show but part of the a.i performances) Before she was just boring, now she’s annoying as well. How anyone can take Heejun seriously is beyond me….teenboppers, I guess. Once the Pinoys leave after Jess’s defeat, they will return. you should be banned here…Matthew branden? I thought the judges were overly critical of Hollie–she sounded and looked great. American Idol Results: Who Won American Idol 2020? I don’t think she has any chance of winning despite her talent, so the save should be used on somebody who does have a good chance of winning. How fortunate we are that it is open not only to America but internationally. I agree with the B+. B+ for jessica ? ‘American Idol’ 2012: Top 10 Idolettes move on to summer tour, one is sent packing. Now tell me if she doesn’t connect! At this point in the game I think just about everyone thought Colton was going to sing his way all the way to finale. That’s why I hesitate to call a winner on this show anymore. But, good? Time after time / It’s a man’s man’s world – Colton / Joshua !bottom 3: DeAndre, Heejun, ErikaGoing home: DeAndre? Why? The ten performances that I remember most of the season are as follows: Stop Draggin’ My Heart Around: Elise and Phillip. I can’t make you love me- Allsion iraheta Jessica – Stuttering, This songs listed are on my phone and on repeat for quite some time now…and of course I am a Phillips and Jessica Fan…Best of luck on your performances on the finale…, alternative songs: I agree they’re good but not that far above the rest.. and you are just hating on Heejun now. It will be a gross miscarriage of musical justice if either Erika or Elise go home, but they seem to be perennially in danger. He has gone outside his comfort zone 2 out of 3 weeks, whoelse has done that. I see it. Uh..Jessica does NOT rock. Colton- Love the Way You Lie but i know she’s not in trouble. 3 – Elise Testone “Whole Lotta Love” (1 song per singer), Summertime-Fantasia He will probably not be in the bottom 3 tonight, but he honestly should be the one going home!!!!!!!!! Hopefully your loyal readers will return full force at that time. Just saying……………… . . Phillips – Volcano that was not FUNNY at all! They deserved an A+ for their performance. The best performances of the night: Elise! Deandre turned Only The Good Die Young into a Milli Vanilli parody! she should be A++++++++++++++++ The WRITER IS THE MOST STUPID IDOL FAN IN HISTORY… sounds a newbie in American Idol trend. Elise – Vienna Wind beneath my wings- skylar9.Sometimes I cry- deandre8. Joshua is a good technical singer but he is not commercial and has not chance of winning. I think people are way off in putting Hollie in their bottom 3. I think they learned their lesson last year. In addition, she doesn’t seem to connect with Jimmy, the judges or anyone really. Anyway, that is OK… but what is important is the admiration given by Jennifer Holiday for the outstanding rendition done by Jessica. (4th) Colton – You did a good job with the song. I just can’t decide who was best tonight – Colton or Phillip. My bottom 3 5. You probably just don’t like Jessica. I almost forgot about Skyler. I don’t think it was fair the way you judged the contestants, Branden. 10) Joshua – When A Man Loves A Woman She was amazing! I thought he End of Conversation! She’s a great singer. My Middle- 5- Joshua Ledet- Straight up this man can sing. get a life BIATCH. that’s why she’s consistently in the bottom 3. Brooke White singing Let It Be should be in the all time top 10 list. I personally think he did connect blond gal whose ever been on the show. Dude, ’twas a FINALE MOMENT for her. If not Deandre, than probably Erika. She doesn’t hide behind that amateur line of, “I’m an artist, and I want to be my own individual.” She listens to the experts in the industry who know a little bit more of what they’re talking about and tries to apply what they teach her. Stay With Me, Skylar Laine (Top 24 Week). They almost sound obsessed. She, like Leona, has been consistent. Hard for me to say is going to leave because like in previous weeks I was completely bored. I cant believe that this psycho gave Jessica only “B+” WTF! watching their performances, i’m totally bored. I think Jessica’s performance in the song “I Will Always Love You” is boomerang to her. The winner- hopefully Colton. The Climb – Hollie Cavanagh Thanks for your thoughts Matthew and I still respect Branden’s Top 10 List. Now add to it the human element. Because a lot of it just crept into your post. The votes have been cast and the fate is set for one of the young Hopefuls, but we won't hear those American Idol results until later tonight. 1. Last year Haley and James pretty much took 9 out of the top 10 w/ Pia getting the other. Colton knows he’s not Billy Joel, and I thought he covered it excellent. Sorry Dude, just to express what keeps boggling in my mind. In a dream-Bo bice 3- Hollie Cavanagh- Her voice is always beautiful and has quite a range A Dance with my father- Jessica, stop bashing branden. I suspect they will just hold on to it in case someone like Jessica, Phillip, or Colton gets sent home too early. and I also agree with Jessica…I do not get her either. it was a little disrespectful C, Deandre – Ok it was a mediocre performance. He sang a song that I used to hate and turned it into something I would buy! Hejuun was absolutely horrible and insulting!!! So, with that being said the bottom two I agree that she looks cold in her performance and I guess its because of her age. Just don’t get carried away with Branden’s comments. Aside from the bad advice from Diddy and Tommy Hilfiger, that is. If I were him, I would not have known what to do either. stupid comment…what do you think about the 3 judges & the audience? I’m good lol its just my opinion about a contestant on American Idol…not the end of the world. Emotions with no proof or logic. Erika. 101% DISAGREE! Sweet dream – jessica sanchez This site has been around way before this year and next year, I will log on when all goes live again… Branden and Matt, wish we had your fresh view on our local idols. Jessica was great singing “I Will Always Love You,” but I think most people are remembering that performance and still judging her on that. This is a very good list! 1. Heejun(He won’t be going home this week thank god but he will likely be in the bottom 3. I think Hollie’s alil bit pitchy… Colton – – -perfect song choice. 7. Not great and not bad at the same time. I don’t get u . Bottom 3: DeAndre, Elise, Heejun Seriously? He had a The two whom the judges gave standing ovations deserves waaaaaaaaay better grades. 5. SPOILER ALERT! I notice now that the producers show the worst bits of their rehearsals with Jimmy to show progression, and she really did progress over the week!I knew one song in the whole show: Piano Man. This year watching most of the contestants leaves me wondering why I am watching this. No more drama- josh ledet BTW, I heard a lot of sharp notes from Hollie, she was pitchy all throughout. IMHO he was the weakest tonight. I would love Jessica bringing home the bacon!!!!! Though, the others are doing very well also. REID GRIMM DID DESERVE THAT SPOT…CLEARLY. I may not quite your like you attitude, but your strong personality is what keeping your voice strong. – Heejun She deserves more than that like maybe an A. DeAndre sang the right lyrics Branden. Matthew, no one said that Jessica runs the show. It’s A Man’s Man’s Man’s World, Joshua Ledet (Top 4 Week). She has a good instrument but there is no soul in her singing yet. Sorry guys! Sure..and I bet she does a much better job than Jessica on that song. Although I like Heejun, but we need to remind everyone that this is a “singing” competition. Haley was in the bottom three a lot of times, but she ended up in 3rd place. probably saturday afternoon. Since Phillip is my favorite, I could say he should be listed in all top ten spots but I think this is a pretty fair and accurate list. 10. I’m not a big fan of Colton but he out did himself last night. Jessica was good but a bit boring. It made non-fans fans and made her fans love her even more. Erika – (A-) but it was ok. That WAS a joke, right? Top 3 for me (feel free to disagree) – Philip, Colton and Elise I am a P2 fan and am hoping but Jessica is amazing. Not my favorite performance of his, but Skylar – Where Do Broken Hearts Go it’s obvoius that most of the top performances came from the last persons left in the competition and it’s true.10. If none of those 2, maybe a little more of Jimmy’s comments. and that would be colton and philip.. Its ok with me..as long as hollie and jessica will be part of top 5.. Hollie 18 . The beginning was a little bit of a yawn, but by the end of the But juliet simms of ” the voice ” would run circles around her in the same rock genre. I am done trying to convince some of the people here that this is a singing competition so I will concede and starting tonight I have given this show a new name “American Attitude”. I know! That was hard to do off the top of my head. 2. And when he pulled out this song during Billy Joel week, the deal seemed to be sealed. In my opinion, he did try. And Elise has been in the bottom 3 weeks in a row now. We all have our own bet for every season, we just hope that she/he delivers an awesome performance every week and honestly I go for Jessica Sanchez simply because she has the best talent for this season and definitely the most deserving to watch! But I would personally prefer a girl winning hoping that idol will produce a female power belter or a rnb singer aside from those country singers and P R E T T Y we don’t need your alibi faces that now you see and now you don’t careers. This was way back at Top 24/25 when we first learned that Skylar was full of spunk and energy. Yes, Jessica can sing..but she reminds me of a wind up doll. Harder than I thought. Only people I think they’d save tomorrow shouldn’t be in the bottom. So..Steven Tyler is good looking? Jessica supporter here.. but My Top 10 would be. (A+). ELISE:-was the best A ++,she is the most unique of the entire competion! I voted for Colton was the best this week and if the season was going to be ending I would say Jessica would be the winner. And just for the record, nobody screams as much as Skyler. Elise does not deserve to go home or be in the bottom 3. Going Home: DeAndre. They really know music , have a unique style and both are very handsome men! He can do so much more. Its pretty obvious that elise is not connected with the people and if they will save her, she will just be eliminated in the comin weeks. Jessica is a major contestant in this competition. Those are the only four that matters. HeeJun is making a mockery of this competition and I think thats sooo wrong. Woah, that was hard. whew! I agree with Mary…. But, I have to say whoever dressed her need to be fired. No….because when she tried she embarrassed herself. Bottom 3 should be: Deandre, Heejun, and Hollie. I was actually surprised just how amazing it turned out, considering what a tacky, dated song that is today. Colton is a great artist. 10. BUT I don’t think they’ll have anything to worry about because I think this might be it for Deandre. It’s a review—-and it should be taken OBJECTIVELY. but i just wanted the owner of this site to realize that fans of jessica make this site famous . 7 – Hollie Cavanagh “All The Man That I Need” My Top- 1-COLTON DIXON- his version of Piano man was solid gold amazing , by far his best performance yet overall vocally and visually. The second best song was “An I am telling you”, and you didn’t even mention it? Also…after listening to the recordings every week…I’ve also developed my opinions based on the recordings. Preview American Idol 2012 Top 10 Guest Performers.